Piece against the forthcoming RSM sale... The Royal Society of Medicine is putting some of its rarest books and photographs up for sale at Christie’s this month. Is this a case of medical negligence?
[BPH edit: part of the key text is here. Read the full piece at the link below] The Royal Society of Medicine (RSM) is to sell some of the most prized books in its historic library at Christie’s, London, on 10 December. The sale consists of 99 lots chosen from across the collection, including rare and unique volumes...Christie’s explains that selections for the sale were made after extensive back and forth with RSM decision-makers. Yet it is hard to see how certain items were deemed expendable, such as 22 early photographs by Hugh Welch Diamond of psychiatric patients from the Surrey County Lunatic Asylum, made in the 1850s. Photographs by Diamond are exceedingly scarce and represent major developments in psychiatric and photographic history. Diamond theorised that portraits made of patients could be used to both document and treat them, since sitters could be shown their pictures to help them better understand the state they were in.
https://apollo-magazine.com/royal-society-medicine-christies-auction-rare-books-photographs/
BPH notes: the sale was reported here: https://britishphotohistory.ning.com/profiles/blogs/auction-hugh-welch-diamond-and-early-photography-london-10-decemb In a follow up the RSM supplied a comment which was taken from the sale press release:
“Proceeds will be directly invested into strengthening the RSM's offer, delivering clear benefits for their members: modernised spaces, enhanced digital platforms, and expanded learning opportunities. Items not yet online will be professionally digitised, ensuring lasting access to educate and inspire generations to come.”
It referred subsequent enquries to Christie's. Specific questions to the RSM were not asnwered directly beyond the statement noted, and the same questions, below, have also been put to Christie's:
- What criteria was used to determine what is to be sold?
- What is the reason behind the sale?
- What will the money raised be used for?
- In view of Christie’s buyer’s premium, can you confirm that the RSM negotiated no commission/charges on the sale to maximise the income to the Society?
In the event the photographs are sold to a buyer outside of the UK then RSM may have to wait for its money as they will be likely subject to an export licence.